(Non-toxic sunscreen in a nutshell: You want zinc and titanium dioxide, which physically block all the bad sun stuff. The other stuff chemically blocks it and then you get all the chemicals all up in your business.)
I actually tried two (bought one for Travis and a different one for me), and have been perfectly happy with both options.
BurnOut - SPF 32
Per Anjali's suggestion, I picked up this guy at Whole Foods (same price as on Amazon):
:: burnout eco-sensitive with zinc, $17.99 for 3.4 oz ::
At first I thought $18 seemed a little steep for what is basically a drugstore sunscreen (let's face it: Whole Foods is nice, but you're buying your stuff at a grocery store...), but I feel like Neutrogena is $13 for 2 ounces, so this is fine. It just seems weird to pay $20 for a beauty product at a grocery store.
What I like about it: SPF 32; crazy high zinc content (18.6%!); wears normally under makeup; is biodegradable and ocean safe (you won't kill the coral reefs!).
What I don't like about it: The bottle says to reapply every two hours. Um... for real? It's just not happening on a daily basis. So I hope I've been okay with my normal weekday routine of: sunscreen, makeup, out the door... all day... the end.
In the meantime, I've also tried...
Burt's Bees Radiance Day Lotion - SPF 15
Well, it definitely has a dreamier name than BurnOut. It's also more expensive. (Although I think I found it on another website for $12 or $13 when I bought it.)
:: burt's bees radiance day lotion, $17.99 for 2 oz. ::
This sunscreen contains the ingredient "fragrance", which all in-the-know non-toxic peeps know is a dirty word. (The perfume industry has made "fragrance" a trade secret, so it can be loaded with all sorts of crazy toxic chemicals and nobody has to disclose it.) However, my understanding of the Burt's Bees brand is that they are really careful about what they put in, so I'm not too alarmed by this ingredient, given the brand.
Overall, I'd say this one feels more like your standard not non-toxic facial moisturizer/sunscreen, if you're a stickler for texture.
I'll probably stick with the BurnOut for regular use, given its higher SPF and zinc content and my fair complexion, but I could see a world where I turn to Burt's Bees in the winter when it's drier and less sunny. I also prefer the Burt's Bees scent, but don't mind the BurnOut one at all.
Have you tried any good sunscreens lately? What about body sunscreens?